Most Haunted Hotels in New York

  • Item thumbnail
    3

    EHP Rating: 92.3

    Adelphi Hotel

    Saratoga Springs, New York
    Haunted by a lady in Victorian era clothing wearing a blue dress, numerous guests of the hotel claim to have seen her walking through the hotel. *Closed for renovations as of Nov 2012....
  • Item thumbnail
    8

    EHP Rating: 90.9

    Red Coach Inn

    Niagara Falls, New York
    The historic Red Coach Inn is said to be haunted, particularly in the Victoria Suite where, in 1927, a man bludgeoned his new bride to death. Guests have reported temperature drops and creaking noises. The inn was featured in an episode of TV's Celebrity Ghost Stories, talked about by actor Bernie...
  • Item thumbnail
    9

    EHP Rating: 87.3

    The Shanley Hotel

    Napanoch, New York
    I'll be honest, I am always a little leery of places that market themselves primarily as a haunted hotel. It's different to be a HAUNTED HOTEL than a hotel that happens to be haunted. I can never decide if they are taking advantage of the craze with smoke and mirrors. In any event, the Shanley...
  • Item thumbnail
    10

    EHP Rating: 86.9

    Belhurst Castle

    Geneva, New York
    Reportedly haunted by a "white lady" apparition, Belhurst boasts a colorful past that urban legend has richly embellished. Many attribute the haunting to the ghost of an opera singer who died there. Some even further embellish the tale by claiming she died while attempting to escape from her...
  • Item thumbnail
    3

    EHP Rating: 85.7

    Naples Hotel

    Naples, New York
    Naples Hotel was built in 1895 and is rumored to be haunted by 6 or more ghosts. One is a man named Topper; another is a woman who has her ghostly children in tow. According to witnesses, the ghosts like to lock doors, turn on the lights, and move pictures around. Ghost tours are...
  • Item thumbnail
    0

    EHP Rating: 85.2

    Bird and Bottle Inn

    Garrison, New York
    Reportedly haunted by the ghost of Emily Warren, the woman who lived there originally. People claim to see a hazy figure and reportedly hear her singing. ...
  • Item thumbnail
    10

    EHP Rating: 82.9

    Holiday Inn - Byblos Niagara

    Grand Island, New York
    This Holiday Inn is reported to have a ghost -- a little girl named Tanya who runs through the halls. She is said to be the spirit of a girl who perished in a fire at a house that once stood on the grounds. She has been seen jumping on beds as well; both guests and employees have witnessed the...
  • Item thumbnail
    4

    EHP Rating: 82.4

    Sagamore Resort

    Bolton, New York
    This restored 1883 resort is believed to have been haunted at least since the 1950s. One of the spirits was a little boy who used to sell found golf balls to the pro shop for extra cash. He was killed after being hit by a car, and his spirit is still seen chasing golf balls on the course. Inside...
  • Item thumbnail
    7

    EHP Rating: 81.8

    The Otesaga Resort Hotel

    Cooperstown, New York
    People report hearing unseen children laughing and playing in the hallway on the third floor and strange voices in the "Glimmerglass Room". Additionally people claim to have seen full-body apparitions strolling though the corridors and grounds, dressed in period clothing....
  • Item thumbnail
    14

    EHP Rating: 81.6

    Oneida Community Mansion House

    Oneida, New York
    The Mansion House, a bed-and-breakfast, is said to have two haunted floors, the bottom two of the building. However, reports say these floors are not open for...
  • Item thumbnail
    7

    EHP Rating: 81.5

    Brae Loch Inn

    Cazenovia, New York
    Brae Loch Inn was once the William Burr Estate, built in 1805. According to reports, Rooms 11 and 12 are especially haunted. Around the inn, visitors may discover strange noises and apparitions of "Scotty," a man in a kilt; a young girl in a blue dress carrying a tray of candles; and a shadowy male...
  • Item thumbnail
    0

    EHP Rating: 81.3

    The Big Moose Inn

    Eagle Bay, New York
    The Big Moose Inn is allegedly haunted by the ghost of a pregnant woman named Grace who was murdered there. Her lover was convicted of hitting her on the head and throwing her in the lake to drown. It is believed that you can still see her ghost wandering the lake shoreline....
  • Item thumbnail
    2

    EHP Rating: 80.0

    The Hulbert House

    Boonville, New York
    The Hulbert House is a self-proclaimed haunted mansion originally built in 1812. Among the ghostly activity here are apparitions, the sounds of children playing, heavy footsteps and touches from unseen hands. The place has been featured on TV's Haunted Collector and is open for haunted sleepovers...
  • Item thumbnail
    0

    EHP Rating: 80.0

    Mill House Inn

    East Hampton, New York
    Some people believe that the ghost of the former owner still haunts the Inn but sightings are few and far between. ...
  • Item thumbnail
    1

    EHP Rating: 80.0

    Allegiance Bed and Breakfast

    Mount Morris, New York
    The historic 1838 building that houses Allegiance Bed & Breakfast and once was an overflow house for the Underground Railroad is believed to be home to two ghosts: Karen and Ray. They have been seen by guests three times, all on the second floor. Karen sits in a corner or at the top of the...
  • Item thumbnail
    10

    EHP Rating: 78.8

    Roycroft Inn

    East Aurora, New York
    Footsteps, voices and apparitions are all heard and seen at the Roycroft Inn. Some people believe that it is haunted by Elbert Hubbard who founded the Roycroft campus and building in an effort to encourage and promote local artistry. Elbert died on the Lusitania when it was sunk by the Germans in...
  • Item thumbnail
    0

    EHP Rating: 77.8

    Miles Wine Cellars

    Himrod, New York
    Miles Wine Cellars, a winery and inn, has made its own wine in honor of its ghosts. Called Ghost, it is a blend of Chardonnay and Cayuga wines. The place is haunted by a ghost that has manifested as a mist that slams doors. Actually, legend has it that there are two ghosts here, a couple who died...
  • Item thumbnail
    2

    EHP Rating: 77.3

    Lindenwald Haus

    Elmira, New York
    Lindenwald Haus has been housing aged and destitute men, women and orphans for 140 years. As the need to house civil war widows waned the owner entered into an agreement with the city of Elmira to provide housing and shelter for local residents. The original charter for the building was to...
  • Item thumbnail
    10

    EHP Rating: 77.1

    Mohonk Mountain House

    High Falls, New York
    Although rumors of this place being haunted are vague and unsubstantiated, some employees and locals claim that this hotel is actually the place that inspired the Overlook hotel in Stephen King's "The Shining". As Stephen King has himself stated that a certain "Colorado resort" (
  • Item thumbnail
    12

    EHP Rating: 75.9

    Hotel Lenhart

    Bemus Point, New York
    Hotel Lenhart, which dates back to 1880s, was rebuilt in 1890 after a fire and partially restored again in 1941, after another fire. An unknown haunt is said to reside in the building, opening and closing doors and tugging at the hair of...
  • Item thumbnail
    3

    EHP Rating: 75.8

    Maplewood Hotel

    Cassadaga, New York
    Located in Lily Dale, NY the heart of the spiritualist movement, Maplewood Hotel is allegedly haunted by numerous spirits. An old hotel, it lacks some of the modern amenities travelers are used to, but it's apparently a good fit for the spook crowd....
  • Item thumbnail
    1

    EHP Rating: 73.1

    The Historic Old Bermuda Inn

    Staten Island, New York
    Believed to be haunted by the home's original mistress Martha Mesereau whose husband died fighting the Civil War. Legend has it that her restless spirit continues to occupy the former mansion, waiting endlessly for her husband to return to her. People see her in the dining room (which was her...
  • Item thumbnail
    0

    EHP Rating: 68.8

    Hotel Chelsea

    New York, New York
    There is no way to list all the famous people who are attached to or have stayed at the Hotel Chelsea. A veritable palace of bohemia indulgence, the creativity, sexy and above all drugs that soaked the halls of the Chelsea would be enough to have you seeing ghosts, even if there weren't any to...
  • Item thumbnail
    1

    EHP Rating: 68.4

    Aurora Inn

    Aurora, New York
    Haunted by a typical White Lady type haunting, this apparition is said to appear throughout the inn. In addition a male ghost is spied occasionally along the lake shoreline near the Inn....
  • Item thumbnail
    0

    EHP Rating: 66.7

    The Algonquin Hotel

    New York, New York
    A famous literary hotspot for a collective of artists and authors' known for their vicious wit and referred to as the Round Table during the 20's, many luminaries lunched daily at the ALgonquin and many keep coming back even after their death to continue the good times and good conversations. Both...
  • Item thumbnail
    10

    EHP Rating: 66.7

    Sherwood Inn

    Greene, New York
    So when you go on the "internets" to look up the Sherwood Inn the ubiquitous description states that "A female committed suicide here". A female what? Howler monkey? Pony? In any case a female of some sort is alleged to have died and now roams the place....
  • Item thumbnail
    1

    EHP Rating: 66.7

    Batcheller Mansion Inn

    Saratoga Springs, New York
    The 1873 Batcheller Mansion Inn was originally home to Civil War veteran and prominent political figure George Sherman Batcheller. Both staff and visitors have reported meeting up with ghosts in the...
  • Item thumbnail
    0

    EHP Rating: 63.6

    Townsend Manor Inn

    Greenport, New York
    The scariest thing about this Inn might be the online reviews, with people reporting paying over $200 a night for motel-quality amenities. The ghost reports are vague and not particularly interesting tapping at windows (gee, no one has heard of birds?) and scratching at doors....
  • Item thumbnail
    0

    EHP Rating: 61.5

    Brightside on Raquette

    Raquette Lake, New York
    This secluded inn, which is only accessible via water taxi, is alleged to be haunted by the ghost of a woman whose husband disappeared from the inn one night during a blizzard. The story claims that she remains in the room waiting for her husband and can frequently seen there. She will only leave...
  • Item thumbnail
    1

    EHP Rating: 60.0

    The Edge of Thyme

    Candor, New York
    The owners of this B&B claim to hear footsteps walking on an uninterrupted wooden floor, despite the home having rugs on the floors. Guests have also reported waking up and seeing a White Lady ghost with blond hair standing at the foot of their bed....
  • Item thumbnail
    2

    EHP Rating: 58.8

    Smith-Ely Mansion

    Clyde, New York
    Built around 1850, the Smith-Ely Mansion is said to be home to ghosts of former inhabitants and more recent suicide...
  • Item thumbnail
    1

    EHP Rating: 57.1

    Red Coach Inn

    Niagara Falls, New York
    The Red Coach Inn is known for it's two ghosts: A Bride, bludgeoned to death in the Victoria Suite in 1925, often seen in the restaurant, early mornings, as well as visiting other Suites. And a 4 year old girl who passed in a barn fire far earlier in the history of the location as an Inn and...
  • Item thumbnail
    5

    EHP Rating: 46.2

    Sutherland House

    Canandaigua, New York
    Locals once referred to this house as "The Haunted House" due to its state of disrepair and shabby appearance. It is now fixed up and runs as a bed and breakfast but there doesn't seem to be anything ghostly happening there....
  • Item thumbnail
    0

    EHP Rating: 46.2

    Wing's Castle

    Millbrook, New York
    Wing’s Castle was built by artists Peter and Toni Ann Wing and was featured on TV's Extreme Homes. The medieval-style castle is rumored to be haunted and is open for tours and overnight...
  • Item thumbnail
    1

    EHP Rating: 37.5

    The Pillars Estate

    Albion, New York
    The Pillars Estate is a Victorian mansion built in the early 1800s. Here, a recreation of the story of Titanic is put on every April. Ghost hunting is not allowed, and overnight guests have to sign a waiver saying they will not conduct séances or otherwise disturb the ghosts who reside here....
  • Item thumbnail
    3

    EHP Rating: 37.5

    Steph's Pond Nudist Park

    Williamson, New York
    We're not able to give out the exact location of this nudist resort (for obvious reasons), but if you're truly interested in visiting you can always contact them for an invitation via their web site link, below. (It's invites-only there.) The story goes that visitors to the retreat often hear...