-
0Posey Chapel
Rolling Prairie, Indiana
7.1 miles from New Carlisle, IN
According to stories, over 150 years the church burned down and its preacher hanged himself from the tree near the gate. Now, folks say red eyes and a red light are seen here and in the woods. Orbs and the voice of a woman singing to guitar music also have ...
Read more » -
0
Saint Mary's College - Le Mans Hall
Notre Dame, Indiana
13 miles from New Carlisle, IN
A scary apparition of a girl hanging from a noose has been witnessed at the Le Mans Hall bell tower. Legend has it that she committed suicide in that very spot years ago. Also, the infirmary on the fourth floor is said to sport blood stains resulting from a girls' ...
Read more » -
0
Tippecanoe Place
South Bend, Indiana
13.1 miles from New Carlisle, IN
Tippecanoe Place is a restaurant within the Studebaker Mansion, once owned by Clement Studebaker of automobile fame. Studebaker's child and nanny were seriously injured when a fire broke out in the nursery and he killed himself not long after. Employees see things moving from the corner of their eye and ...
Read more » -
0
Holiday Inn City Center
South Bend, Indiana
13.4 miles from New Carlisle, IN
Pilots and flight attendants staying at this hotel have reported seeing a ghostly flight attendant in the mirror and sitting on the edge of their beds. Rumor has it she was killed by a pilot at the hotel. Now known as the Magnuson Grand Hotel South Bend.
Read more » -
0
Potato Creek State Park
North Liberty, Indiana
13.7 miles from New Carlisle, IN
Potato Creek State Park has 327 acres of fields, woodlands, prairies and wetlands. It is said to be haunted by ghostly children who have drowned here while swimming or fishing over the years. The plaintive sound of a child crying or calling for its mother has been rumored to come ...
Read more » -
0
University of Notre Dame
Notre Dame, Indiana
13.9 miles from New Carlisle, IN
"Win one for the Gipper" is a term that references the University of Notre Dame ghost George Gipp, a legendary Notre Dame footballer. His ghost is reputed to haunt Washington Hall ever since he died from strep throat in December 1920. He manifests as night noises and footsteps, slamming doors, ...
Read more » -
0
Hacienda Restaurant
Mishawaka, Indiana
16.7 miles from New Carlisle, IN
Once a private mansion, Hacienda Mexican Restaurant is rumored to be haunted by apparitions of those who used to live here. Some stories say one apparition belongs to a maid with whom the mansion's owner had an affair. When the maid became pregnant, he shunned her, so she hanged herself ...
Read more » -
0
Frost Cemetery
Dowagiac, Michigan
23.8 miles from New Carlisle, IN
If you drive by there is also a head stone that glows green. You can hear giggling from insides the cemetery late at night. And you will sometimes see figures hiding among the stone. (Submitted by Kollin)
Read more » -
0
Ruthmere Mansion
Elkhart, Indiana
27.7 miles from New Carlisle, IN
Ruthmere Mansion is rumored to be haunted; witnesses say the ghosts set off alarms and sirens inside the mansion especially on Halloween. Some report the sound of phantom gunshots here as well. It should be noted that employees at the house museum say they have never experienced any hauntings here.
Read more » -
0
Winchester Mansion
Elkhart, Indiana
27.7 miles from New Carlisle, IN
The 1905 Winchester Mansion is home to the ghost of former resident Nellie Knickerbocker, some say. Folks working at the businesses housed in the mansion have noted the attic light coming on by itself, objects falling off shelves, and strange sounds. Reports tell us that when Nellie Knickerbocker was alive, ...
Read more » -
Haunted Tales from The Region: Ghosts of Indiana's South Shore (Haunted America)
Dorothy Salvo Davis
-
0
Lerner Theatre
Elkhart, Indiana
27.8 miles from New Carlisle, IN
Lerner Theatre is believed to be haunted by the ghost of a tech director who had a heart attack and died on the job. Witnesses say lights flicker and strange sounds come from the attic, and a ghostly figure, some say, can be seen in the second-floor box seats when ...
Read more » -
0
Olympia Books
Dowagiac, Michigan
28.3 miles from New Carlisle, IN
Olympia Books is no longer in operation according to reports, but it is said to have a ghost named Mr. Bock. His name comes from lettering stenciled in the hallway that leads to the apartment upstairs. The ghost has been known to knock books off of shelves or place them ...
Read more » -
0
Beckwith Theatre Company
Dowagiac, Michigan
28.4 miles from New Carlisle, IN
Dating back to the 1800s, the theater company is haunted by a young Depression-era girl. Her apparition has in rare cases been seen, sometimes along with whispers or laughter, but more often witnesses will find that their personal objects have been moved or hidden.
Read more » -
0
Indiana Dunes State Park
Chesterton, Indiana
28.7 miles from New Carlisle, IN
Around 1915, this area was mostly wilderness, and stories often came from fishermen about a naked woman who would swim in the lake. She was said to be Alice Marble Gray, a hermit who lived along the beach. She was the daughter of a Chicago couple and was cultured and ...
Read more » -
0
Valparaiso University
Valparaiso, Indiana
31.9 miles from New Carlisle, IN
At the Alumni Hall at Valparaiso University, two ghost children, age 8 or 9 and wearing jogging pants, are known to run up and down the hallways at about 2 a.m. According to some of the student residents, the ghosts have spoken to them and told them they were playing ...
Read more » -
0
Porter County Jail and Sheriff's House
Valparaiso, Indiana
32.7 miles from New Carlisle, IN
Porter County Jail and Sheriff's House is rumored to be haunted and has been used at Halloween for a haunted house attraction. Witnesses have described many strange occurrences including orbs of light and objects that turn up missing.
Read more » -
0
Old Porter Road
Portage, Indiana
33.7 miles from New Carlisle, IN
The shadowy figures that have been seen along the train tracks by Old Porter Road are a mystery. Some say they are almost doglike, with a tail and glowing yellow eyes. They have been known to run alongside trains and bay into the night.
Read more » -
0
Wolf Mansion - Josephus Wolf House
Valparaiso, Indiana
35.2 miles from New Carlisle, IN
Legend has it that the mansion owner went crazy after slavery was abolished, and in his rage, he killed all of his slaves and their children. Some stories say he even killed his family while he was at it. Then he killed himself. Now, folks say, an unexplained light comes ...
Read more » -
0Inn at Aberdeen
Valparaiso, Indiana
35.7 miles from New Carlisle, IN
A playful haunt at this 1830s-era inn has been known to hide guests' belongings in odd places. For example, one guest's missing lipstick turned up in a shoe. Cold spots and disembodied footsteps also have been reported, and psychic and ghost-hunting teams have determined that there are spirits of a ...
Read more » -
0
Elkheart Civic Theatre
Bristol, Indiana
35.8 miles from New Carlisle, IN
The Elkhart Civic Theatre (aka Bristol Opera House), housed in an 1897 building, is said to be haunted by ghosts who send books and papers flying off shelves, levitate small objects, run sewing machines and project moving shafts of light. Shadows and an apparition of a floating dark-haired woman have ...
Read more » -
0
Dog Face Bridge
La Crosse, Indiana
37.5 miles from New Carlisle, IN
Spooky legends surround this old bridge. The stories involve a honeymooning 1950s couple and a dog that ran out in front of the car, causing them to drive off of the bridge. Reports of many things have been made in the vicinity, including apparitions of bodies, apparitions of a females ...
Read more » -
0
Anderson Cemetery
Lawton, Michigan
40.9 miles from New Carlisle, IN
Anderson Cemetery has a legend that explains a glowing headstone. So the story goes, a man came to the Morris family home and shot the whole family and the maid, then stole a horse. The family was buried here, and on the anniversary of the murder, the headstone is said ...
Read more » -
0
Baums Bridge Inn
Kouts, Indiana
41.3 miles from New Carlisle, IN
This inn is reported to be home to a the apparition of a man surrounded by a dim light. He is said to appear around midnight and may be a bit shy: Rumor has it that if you look at him too long, he will become enraged and appear in ...
Read more » -
0
Carolina Street Demon House
Gary, Indiana
43.6 miles from New Carlisle, IN
The house was said to be haunted by more than 200 demons. Witnesses have reported levitating children, swarms of flies that mysteriously appear in winter, footprints, and apparitions. The demons were believed to have possessed the three children of the family who lived there, and case workers, priests and police ...
Read more » -
0
Old Kosciusko County Jail and Museum
Warsaw, Indiana
46.5 miles from New Carlisle, IN
The Old Kosciusko County Jail was in operation from 1870 to 1982. In 1982 the new Justice Building was completed and took over the housing of the inmates. The Old Jail subsequently became the home of the Kosciusko Historical Society now shares the county Genealogy Library. Employees, volunteers and visitors ...
Read more » -
0
Reeder Road
Griffith, Indiana
48.2 miles from New Carlisle, IN
Local lore about Reder Road tells of Elizabeth Wilson, a hitchhiking ghost who drowned in a swamp when her car went off the road. Her ghost waits at the roadside for a ride to her former house, but she disappears from cars at Ross Cemetery, where she was buried in ...
Read more » -
0
Crown Point Sheriff's House and Jail
Crown Point, Indiana
48.3 miles from New Carlisle, IN
The Crown Point Sheriff's House was built in 1882, and the jail was added on in 1926. This is the very jail from which John Dillinger made his notorious escape in 1934. He used jail-issued razor blades to carved a gun out of part of a wooden washboard. He used ...
Read more » -
0Barbee Hotel
Warsaw, Indiana
50 miles from New Carlisle, IN
This historic hotel was frequented by Al Capone, who would stay in Room 301 and clear out all the rest of the guests so he could be alone. Cleaning staff have smelled cigar smoke coming from his room and have seen an ghostly man sitting in a booth in the ...
Read more » -
0
Whihala Beach
Whiting, Indiana
50.6 miles from New Carlisle, IN
Some say that at Whihala Beach at night, you can see and hear phantom sailboats and apparitions of folks swimming and playing with innertubes in old-fashioned bathing suits.
Read more » -
0
Stallbohm-Kaske House
Munster, Indiana
52.1 miles from New Carlisle, IN
According to locals, the original inn that stood here burned down on Halloween of 1909. And in 1949, resident Wilhelmina Kaske passed away in a front bedroom, and these incidents may have led to the house's hauntings. Witnesses have reported a figure leaning out of the barn window, a presence ...
Read more » -
0
Hawks Head Cemetery - McDowell Cemetery
South Haven, Michigan
55 miles from New Carlisle, IN
Hawks Head Cemetery is allegedly the burial site for Flora, Al Capone's mistress. Her ghost has been reported, wearing a white gauzy dress. Chimes are said to herald her appearance. A dim red light also has been spotted near the middle driveway.
Read more » -
0
Ax-Man's House - Ax-Man's Bridge
Crete, Illinois
56.7 miles from New Carlisle, IN
Legends told by locals say that in the 1970s, a man killed his wife, kids, and two policeman with an ax before hanging their bodies from meat hooks in his shed. When the police found out, he ran from them. The police gave pursuit and shot him in the woods ...
Read more » -
0
Lake Prairie Cemetery
Lowell, Indiana
57.2 miles from New Carlisle, IN
Apparitions of deceased townspeople, ghostly mists, and orbs all have been reported at this cemetery, especially in the southern half, which is the oldest.
Read more » -
0
Green Hornet Trolley Disaster Site
Chicago, Illinois
57.8 miles from New Carlisle, IN
33 people were burned alive when a trolley collided with a tanker carrying gasoline. It is believed that victims may still be here reliving that fateful day. Submitted by Chris Berglund
Read more » -
0John J. Glessner House
Chicago, Illinois
58.3 miles from New Carlisle, IN
The prisonlike 1887 mansion is said to be haunted by its architect, Henry Hobson Richardson. His white apparition has been seen in the bedroom and on the stairs, and cold spots are felt about the mansion.
Read more » -
0
Holmes Death Castle Location
Chicago, Illinois
58.6 miles from New Carlisle, IN
A post office now stands on the former site of the Holmes Death Castle, or Murder Castle, built by serial killer H.H. Holmes. He built the hotel to lure in 1893 Chicago World's Fair visitors, then tortured and murdered his guests, including women and children. In this area, witnesses say ...
Read more » -
0Congress Plaza Hotel
Chicago, Illinois
58.7 miles from New Carlisle, IN
This is one of those hotels that is so old and has so much history floating around it that there are practically as many ghost stories as there are room. The Al Capone one (where people claim to see him waking the halls) however is one that is certainly ...
Read more » -
0
Triple Crown Seafood Restaurant
Chicago, Illinois
58.8 miles from New Carlisle, IN
Housed in an old apartment building, this restaurant is rumoured to be haunted by a former resident. A shadowy apparition has been seen lurking near the bathrooms, and dirty dishes left out overnight have been known to clean themselves. (Submitted by Callum Swift)
Read more » -
0Site of Fort Dearborn
Chicago, Illinois
58.9 miles from New Carlisle, IN
The intersection of Wacker Drive and Michigan Avenue in Chicago's Loop area was once the site of Fort Dearborn. Road workers there found many buried human skeletons, and since then there have been many sightings of ghostly apparitions of 19th-century settlers in the area. The fort is gone now, but ...
Read more » -
0
Drake Hotel
Chicago, Illinois
59 miles from New Carlisle, IN
The historic Drake Hotel's tenth floor is believed to be haunted by a ghostly woman in red. As legend has it, she was at a New Year's Eve party in 1920 when she caught her husband with another woman, and she flung herself to her death from the tenth-floor window.
Read more » -
0Water Tower
Chicago, Illinois
59 miles from New Carlisle, IN
This 1869 limestone tower, one of the symbols of Old Chicago, was built for use in firefighting. It is said to be haunted by a man who died in the Chicago Fire of 1871. Instead of fleeing, the worker stayed to man the pumps, and it is said that when ...
Read more » -
0
Death Alley
Chicago, Illinois
59 miles from New Carlisle, IN
Death Alley is the alley behind the Oriental Theater, formerly the Iroquois Theater, believed to haunted by ghosts from Iroquois Theater Fire on December 30, 1903. The theater was full of nearly 2,000 people when the fire broke out, thought to be caused from faulty wiring, during a vaudeville show ...
Read more » -
0
Chicago Board Options Exchange
Chicago, Illinois
59.1 miles from New Carlisle, IN
A 1979 battle over a trade has resulted in some lingering spirits. The two angry men involved in the conflict decided to step outside, where they fought near the horse statue fountain. One man was hurt so badly that he died before paramedics could help him. Janitors in the building ...
Read more » -
0House of Blues
Chicago, Illinois
59.1 miles from New Carlisle, IN
Reports say the site is haunted by the ghost of a little girl who died of an illness. Witnesses have seen and heard her, and in one instance she was found playing with a living boy's toys. She asked the boy to play with her, but when he screamed, she ...
Read more » -
0Clark Street Bridge
Chicago, Illinois
59.2 miles from New Carlisle, IN
The Eastland Disaster occurred nearby in 1915, in which an overloaded passenger steamer Eastland capsized while still tied to the dock, killing over 800 people. It is said that their moans and cries can still be heard around the Clark Street Bridge.
Read more » -
0The Dome Room - Excalibur Nightclub
Chicago, Illinois
59.2 miles from New Carlisle, IN
This night club is said to be haunted by presences that linger from when it was once used as a makeshift morgue, during the Eastland Disaster in 1915.
Read more » -
0
Benton House
Chicago, Illinois
59.8 miles from New Carlisle, IN
The Benton House, circa 1909, may be haunted by “Ma” Benton. Witnesses have seen apparitions and heard slamming doors and footsteps, and someone unseen has been known to put out the fire in the fireplace. The place was featured on an episode of TV's Ghost Hunters.
Read more » -
0
Adobo Grill
Chicago, Illinois
59.8 miles from New Carlisle, IN
The Victorian-style building that houses the Adobo Grill restaurant was erected in 1872 after the Great Fire ravaged the previously standing bakery factory. It is known to be haunted, and especially active when renovations are made to the building. Folks have reported many different incidents of paranormal phenomena, including seeing ...
Read more » -
0Jane Addams Hull House
Chicago, Illinois
59.8 miles from New Carlisle, IN
Used as a settlement house beginning in the late 19th century, Hull House operated as a place that attempted to influence and improve the lives of the poorer neighbors in the community. The most often repeated story about Hull House (and the inspiration for the story Rosemary's Baby) is that ...
Read more » -
0
The Givens Castle - Beverly Castle Academy
Chicago, Illinois
59.9 miles from New Carlisle, IN
The 1886 limestone-towered castle built by real estate promoter and novelist Robert G. Givens is said to be haunted by his Irish wife, who passed away before she could come to America to live in her castle. Witnesses say her apparition has been seen walking up the hill to the ...
Read more »
» Cemeteries near New Carlisle, IN
» Find museums in New Carlisle, IN
