-
0Mount Olive Cemetery
Bellville, Ohio
3.6 miles from Butler, OH
Mount Olive Cemetery, or Lucas Cemetery, has a ghost named Mary Jane. One legend has it that she was burned at the stake in the 1800s after being accused of witchcraft. Another says she was a Native-American medicine woman, and some folks thought her profession was a mite too close ...
Read more » -
0
Malabar Farm
Lucas, Ohio
4.5 miles from Butler, OH
Pulitzer Prize-winning author Louis Bromfield built Malabar Farm in 1939, and the historic homesite is open for tours and wagon rides. It is said to be haunted by Ceely Rose. According to her story, she was in love with a boy who didn't feel the same. In order to spare ...
Read more » -
0
Pleasant Valley Cemetery
Lucas, Ohio
5 miles from Butler, OH
Pleasant Valley Cemetery is haunted by the Rose Family buried here. Legend has it that Ceely Rose murdered her mother, father and brother in 1896 over her love for Guy Berry. Guy lied and told Ceely they couldn't marry because her family didn't approve of him rather than tell her ...
Read more » -
0
Mansfield Women's Club
Mansfield, Ohio
12.8 miles from Butler, OH
Remaining as one of Mansfield, Ohio's largest and oldest homes, the estate of Mr & Mrs. Henry C. Hedges, is known for its near original 1800's interior and stunning Victorian charm. The home now is the official Club House to the Mansfield Federation of Women's Clubs, was left by widow ...
Read more » -
0
Bissman Building
Mansfield, Ohio
13 miles from Butler, OH
The Bissman Building, once a grocery warehouse built in 1886, is said to be very haunted; ghost hunts and tours are offered here. Many apparitions are seen here, including a man in a long coat and top hat and a young girl; footsteps have been heard on empty floors above, ...
Read more » -
0Ohio State Reformatory
Mansfield, Ohio
14.2 miles from Butler, OH
The prison, defunct since 1990, was the setting for the movie The Shawshank Redemption. It has been used as a setting or featured on many other movies, music videos and TV programs, including Ghost Adventures. Witnesses have experienced shadow figures, slamming cell doors and yelling voices, and female witnesses claim ...
Read more » -
0
Big Four Train Depot
Galion, Ohio
21.3 miles from Butler, OH
This historic depot is heritage-listed, and also believed by many to be one of the towns most haunted buildings. The old train depot has played host to many tragedies and notable events in the town history, so it is easy to see where the basis of these rumours lie. The ...
Read more » -
0
Brownella Cottage and Galion Historical Museum
Galion, Ohio
21.7 miles from Butler, OH
This beautiful cottage houses the town historical society, and is well known for the ghost that reputedly haunts the old building. Although the identity of the apparition is currently unclear, witnesses describe a man dressed in black with white hair who wanders the hallways scaring visitors to the museum. Other ...
Read more » -
0
Millersburg Hotel
Millersburg, Ohio
26.7 miles from Butler, OH
This hotel has been in operation for well over a century, so it is more than likely that some of the spectres in this hotel were guests who never checked out. The owners and staff are displeased with the paranormal activity in the hotel, as they receive various reports ...
Read more » -
0
The Corner House
Warsaw, Ohio
27.2 miles from Butler, OH
This small, abandoned wooden house at the intersection of the two major roads is haunted by the apparition of a woman in black. Her husband murdered her in the house many years ago, and people driving past have reported smelling burning flesh and hearing the screams of a woman. (Submitted by ...
Read more » -
0
Old Sweet Shop
Coshocton, Ohio
35.8 miles from Butler, OH
This historic building turned sweet shop is haunted by a whole horde of ghostly children. Staff have heard running footsteps and ghostly voices, but upon investigation, have found nothing. (Submitted by Callum Swift)
Read more » -
0
Warehouse Restaurant
Coshocton, Ohio
35.9 miles from Butler, OH
This historic warehouse was converted to a popular restaurant, but even back in the late twentieth century, police and authorities were responding to reports of paranormal activity which happened on a frequent basis. The restaurant is believed to be haunted by a ghostly child and the apparition of an ...
Read more » -
0
Bryn Du Mansion
Granville, Ohio
36.2 miles from Butler, OH
The Bryn Du Mansion and grounds comprise a fifty-two acre estate in Granville, Ohio. The property is managed by the Bryn Du Commission, a non-profit organization established by the Village of Granville. The organization follows a mission of historic preservation and providing program and event facilities for the benefit ...
Read more » -
0
Denison University Library
Granville, Ohio
36.2 miles from Butler, OH
The 7th tier of the Denison University Library is said to have a spirit, a shadowy woman wearing an old-fashioned dress. Those who fall asleep here, especially men, have been awoken by her hitting them on the back of the head.
Read more » -
0The Buxton Inn
Granville, Ohio
36.3 miles from Butler, OH
Visit this inn and you may meet the ghost of Orrin Granger, the pioneer who built it in 1812. Or you may spot Major Horton Buxton, after whom the inn was named. Major Buxton operated the inn during the late 1800s. Former innkeeper Bonnie Bounell is also said to have ...
Read more » -
0
Harding Home
Marion, Ohio
36.6 miles from Butler, OH
President Warren G. Harding's Home, open to the public as a museum, is known for its Death Clock and Finch of Doom. The Death Clock, a wedding gift to the Hardings, hangs on the wall above the staircase. On August 2, 1973, at 7:30 p.m., the clock inexplicably stopped. The ...
Read more » -
0
Marion Cemetery - The Revolving Ball
Marion, Ohio
36.7 miles from Butler, OH
Marion Cemetery is a large one with an impressive World War II Memorial, and it's also famous for its Revolving Ball. It's a large stone sphere that's part of the Merchant Family's plot. In 1896, several small black granite spheres were arranged in a large circle, with a 5-foot-tall granite ...
Read more » -
0
Old Licking County Jail
Newark, Ohio
36.8 miles from Butler, OH
The Old Licking County Jail building, constructed in 1889, has an eerie castle-like appearance reminiscent of the Tower of London. In its day it housed many a notorious murderer and serial killer. It was here that Carl Etherington, a Dry-Agent Detective, was once held in a cell for his protection ...
Read more » -
0Prospect Place
Trinway, Ohio
38.1 miles from Butler, OH
The 29-room mansion built in 1856 by abolitionist G.W. Adams is said to have been a stop on the Underground Railroad. The house is said to be haunted by ghosts from its past, and has been featured on TV shows such as Ghost Hunters and Ghost Adventures.
Read more » -
0
Grapevine House Inn
Dundee, Ohio
38.3 miles from Butler, OH
The 1834 bed and breakfast inn is located in the pleasant township of Winesburg, which is often confused with a novel of the same name by Sherwood Anderson. The old building is one of the earliest in the borough, and is rumoured to be haunted by a young girl ...
Read more » -
0
Historic Stoner House
Westerville, Ohio
41.8 miles from Butler, OH
Mystic Nirvana / The Historic Stoner House - it was built in 1852 by George Stoner as an inn and tavern. It also was a station on the Underground Railroad. There was a 'hidden' room in the basement where the runaways would hide out till they could make their ...
Read more » -
0
Rogue's Hollow Bridge
Doylestown, Ohio
46.2 miles from Butler, OH
Rogue's Hollow Bridge, or Crybaby Bridge, has a couple of legends attached to it that may explain the ghostly crying sound heard here. One says that long ago a woman tossed her unwanted newborn over the bridge, and now the phantom scene replays here along with the sound of a ...
Read more » -
0
The Worthington Inn
Worthington, Ohio
46.7 miles from Butler, OH
Spooky happenings reported here include apparitions, unexplained handprints on mirrors, and the smell of phantom cigar smoke.
Read more » -
0Spitzer House Bed and Breakfast
Medina, Ohio
47.8 miles from Butler, OH
At this 19th-century Victorian home-turned-inn, people have witnessed unexplained voices and music, and the piano in the parlor plays songs by itself. The ghost of a stern-looking man is said to appear in Ceilan's Room, and Anna's Room is haunted by a servant girl's spirit. The servant girl also has ...
Read more » -
0
Wyandot County Historical Society
Upper Sandusky, Ohio
47.9 miles from Butler, OH
This 1852 residence was owned by the Beery family for many years, until it was donated to the local historical society in 1962. Since then, visitors and staff have reported various strange occurrences, including ghostly voices, disembodied footsteps and strange whistling noises. The ghost of an elderly woman, suspected ...
Read more » -
0
Warehouse on the Canal
Canal Fulton, Ohio
48 miles from Butler, OH
This 1906 building previously housed the old Finnerock Furniture building and now houses an arcade of quaint shops and restaurants. There have been reported sightings of many ghosts, including numerous apparitions in period clothing wandering around the building. The ghost of a little girl has been seen near the old ...
Read more » -
0
Mirror Lake
Columbus, Ohio
51.3 miles from Butler, OH
Mirror Lake at Ohio State University has a couple of ghosts. One is a student who drowned there in the 1960s, and is sometimes heard splashing and screaming. The other is a jogger who was killed nearby. The jogger apparition creates a cold breeze as he runs and keeps peering ...
Read more » -
0
Capital University
Columbus, Ohio
51.4 miles from Butler, OH
Capital University's Kerns Religious Life Center is said to have a haunted basement. Folks down there have felt unexplained sadness and trouble breathing, and lights are said to come on by themselves. The Science Building may also have a ghost--the spirit of a former biology professor. The sixty-something man's apparition ...
Read more » -
0
Old Governor's Mansion
Columbus, Ohio
51.6 miles from Butler, OH
The presence of a woman who died in a fire within the historic building has been reported. She appears as an African American woman in a blue dress, and has been seen in various rooms of the mansion. During recent renovations, she appeared to staff members and told them how ...
Read more » -
0Harrison House Bed and Breakfast
Columbus, Ohio
51.9 miles from Butler, OH
The house here was originally built in 1890, and when it became a bed-and-breakfast inn in the 1990s, the owners found that they were not alone! Spirits are said to haunt the second and third floors, and can also be found near the front door and first-floor closet. Ghosts said ...
Read more » -
0
Loyal Oak Tavern
Norton, Ohio
52.1 miles from Butler, OH
The old tavern building was built in the 1840s, and was a cabinet shop in its early years. There are remnants of its older days as a tavern, such as a half-log bar in the basement as well as a 1930s keg. But locals here say that's not all that ...
Read more » -
0
Thurber House
Columbus, Ohio
52.2 miles from Butler, OH
Thurber House, a nonprofit literary center and Thurber museum, is believe to be haunted. It was the home of Jamer Thurber, author and "New Yorker" cartoonist, and Thurber himself was reported to have had a ghostly experience. Witnesses now have heard footsteps on the back stairs and seen moving figures ...
Read more » -
0
Walnut Knolls Housing Estate
Columbus, Ohio
52.3 miles from Butler, OH
The building is now vacant, and was previously a mental hospital around fifty years ago. There are reports of people hearing loud footsteps in the building, seeing ghostly lights moving around the upper level and having objects thrown at them by an aggressive entity. (Submitted by Callum Swift)
Read more » -
0
Char Bar
Columbus, Ohio
52.4 miles from Butler, OH
This bar is connected to a labyrinth of tunnels that run underneath the city, which is where the historic buildings haunting's stem from. Staff have observed a hooded spectre in black robes in the basement underneath the building, who vanishes when approached. Upon investigation, staff located the entrance to ...
Read more » -
0
Central Ohio Fire Museum
Columbus, Ohio
52.4 miles from Butler, OH
This historic firehouse was in operation till the late twentieth century, when it was converted and restored as a museum preserving fire fighting heritage and artefacts. Witnesses and staff at the museum claim that is haunted by ghostly thoroughbred horses, who have been heard in the museum late at ...
Read more » -
0The Cobbler Shop Bed and Breakfast
Dover, Ohio
52.6 miles from Butler, OH
Guests at this 1800s inn, which was once a cobbler shop, have heard knocking on their doors when no one was there, and disembodied footsteps in the hallway. Those who have seen the ghost here say he is a man wearing a long dark coat.
Read more » -
0
The Cobbler Shop Bed and Breakfast
Dover, Ohio
52.6 miles from Butler, OH
Guests at this 1800s inn, which was once a cobbler shop, have heard knocking on their doors when no one was there, and disembodied footsteps in the hallway. Those who have seen the ghost here say he is a man wearing a long dark coat.
Read more » -
0
Books N' Things
Dover, Ohio
52.6 miles from Butler, OH
This old store was in operation for many years, but now appears to be a private residence. While it was in operation, customers would smell the aroma of coffee, even when there was none brewing. The ghost was kind to the owners, and would often tuck them into bed ...
Read more » -
0
Zoar Historic Hotel
Zoar, Ohio
52.6 miles from Butler, OH
This historic hotel has been acquired by the state historical society and is due to be renovated to restore it to its former glory. The hotel is rumoured to be haunted, which has been testified by many former guests, patrons and staff, and is widely acclaimed to be the ...
Read more » -
0
Elevator Brewery and Draught Haus
Columbus, Ohio
52.7 miles from Butler, OH
The ghost of a colonel murdered here by a woman he loved has been reported in the tavern. His apparition, which appears as a ghostly ball of light, has been observed floating around the building. Footsteps often appear in the snow outside the tavern when there is no one around. (Submitted ...
Read more » -
0
Ohio Statehouse
Columbus, Ohio
52.8 miles from Butler, OH
The Ohio Statehouse is a Greek Revival building that houses the government of Ohio. It is said to be haunted by former worker Tom Bateman, whose ghost appears on the staircase at 5 p.m. daily. The ghost is also said to turn lights of and on and move objects.
Read more » -
0
Columbus Cultural Arts Center
Columbus, Ohio
53.3 miles from Butler, OH
This historic castle-like building is believed to be haunted by at least two apparitions. The first is a woman in period clothing who appears in the pottery room of the establishment. She is believed to be a woman who was involved in a public hanging nearby, although why she ...
Read more » -
0
Schmidt's German Restaurant
Columbus, Ohio
53.5 miles from Butler, OH
This historic eatery is housed in an old horse stable, and serves up delicious food and some rather interesting ghost tales. The building is believed to be haunted by a friendly former owner, who has been seen in the main dining room and has been known to move chairs ...
Read more » -
0
Siesta Motel
Norwich, Ohio
53.7 miles from Butler, OH
This motel is said to be haunted by the spirit of an angry man who had been staying at the night there after a fight with his mother. And as it so happened, that night he was the victim of a burglary. The still-enraged man attacked the burglar upon finding ...
Read more » -
0
Greater Columbus Antiques Mall
Columbus, Ohio
54 miles from Butler, OH
This antiques arcade is haunted by many apparitions, which is not hard to believe as the building was previously a funeral home. The first apparition reported in the building is a tall man in a brown suit, who has been seen walking around, and in some cases through the antiques ...
Read more » -
0
Clay Haus Restaurant
Somerset, Ohio
54.4 miles from Butler, OH
This restaurant is housed in a historic building, which was built over the site of a civil war house. During the levelling of the lower floor, the current owners dug out the basement using their hands, and came across many interesting artefacts, which are on display in the main ...
Read more » -
0
Clay Haus
Somerset, Ohio
54.4 miles from Butler, OH
Clay Haus, a restaurant that serves German and American fare, is believed to be haunted. Witnesses have seen apparitions, heard knocks and footsteps and felt eerie presences.
Read more » -
0
Doc Henderson's Restaurant - The Castle Bed and Breakfast
Marysville, Ohio
55 miles from Butler, OH
Although this reataurant is currently closed for repairs, it seems to be a favorite spot for the haunts. Folks here have seen a black shadowy figure and have witnessed an eerie, uneasy feeling in the building.
Read more » -
0
Dutch Mill Truck Stop - The Windmill
Carey, Ohio
55.3 miles from Butler, OH
Formerly a restaurant and filling station, the building is supposedly haunted by a ghostly man carrying a leather briefcase. His association with the place is unknown. (Submitted by Callum Swift)
Read more » -
0
Camp Chase Confederate Cemetery
Columbus, Ohio
56.2 miles from Butler, OH
At Camp Chase Confederate Cemetery there is a weeping Lady in Gray who visits, leaving flowers on a soldier's grave. She wears a Civil War-era gray suit and has been heard crying.
Read more »
» Cemeteries near Butler, OH
» Find museums in Butler, OH
