-
0Papa John's Pizza
Seymour, Indiana
20.5 miles from Butlerville, IN
At this Papa John's Pizza location, several witnesses have reported an apparition in a blue uniform and knocking sounds coming from the walls. The knocks seemed to come from the empty store adjacent to Papa John's.
Read more » -
0
Jefferson County Library
Madison, Indiana
21.7 miles from Butlerville, IN
Rumor has it that the ornery ghost of a young man rides the elevator rubbing and patting women. He is believed to have lived here when it was a private home and was confined to a wheelchair, which is why the elevator originally was installed. Some reports say the ghost ...
Read more » -
0
Broadway Historic Hotel and Tavern
Madison, Indiana
21.7 miles from Butlerville, IN
The historic hotel and restaurant appears to be popular with the spirit set. The apparition of a disruptive criminal shot dead on the premises has been reported in the main dining room, while the bed and breakfast quarters of the establishment are supposedly haunted by an unknown woman in ...
Read more » -
0
Ohio Theater
Madison, Indiana
21.8 miles from Butlerville, IN
Local tales tell of lights that seem to float in the balcony area and then disappear. It is also said that at midnight, the sound of screaming can be heard.
Read more » -
0
Hanover College
Hanover, Indiana
22.2 miles from Butlerville, IN
At Parker Auditorium, the ghost of Dr. A.G. Parker, past college president of the college, has been seen and heard, along with unexplained sounds and missing objects. And at Donner Residence Hall's east wing, the ghost of a student who committed suicide in a dorm room is blamed for objects ...
Read more » -
0
Hanover Cemetery
Hanover, Indiana
22.6 miles from Butlerville, IN
Visitors here have reported feeling unexplained nausea and chills, possibly related to the grave of Benjamin Bennett, who is believed to have drowned in the Ohio River (although his body was never found).
Read more » -
0
Quality Machine and Tool Works
Columbus, Indiana
24.5 miles from Butlerville, IN
Quality Machine and Tool Works is rumored to be home to the ghost of a former employee who hanged himself because of an unrequited love. Shadowy apparitions and disappearing objects are blamed on the ghost.
Read more » -
0
Crump Theatre
Columbus, Indiana
24.7 miles from Butlerville, IN
The 1874 Crump Theatre , once a vaudeville and opera house, is home to some spooky goings-on. Ghost men and children have been seen along with unexplained noises and fragrances. Music has been heard coming from the top of a stairway. Reports say the building is no longer open to ...
Read more » -
0
Scott County Heritage Center
Scottsburg, Indiana
28.6 miles from Butlerville, IN
The Scott County Heritage Center and Museum is housed in a building that was once the county poor farm. It is said to be haunted by former residents. Witnesses have described footsteps on the second floor when no one is up there, unexplained smells, a baby crying, and lights coming ...
Read more » -
0
Scott County Historical Museum
Scottsburg, Indiana
28.6 miles from Butlerville, IN
Originally constructed in 1892 after the county seat moved to Scottsburg, the building served for many years as the district poor farm. During conversion to house the historical society, staff and workers allegedly encountered resistance of a paranormal kind. Visitors have reported hearing babies crying, disembodied footsteps on the ...
Read more » -
0
Bridgewater Cemetery
Scottsburg, Indiana
29.4 miles from Butlerville, IN
The isolated hilltop Bridgewater Cemetery is known to have a glowing tombstone. The grave is that of a man who appears in ghostly form at night to guard the cemetery's gate.
Read more » -
0Schenck Mansion
Vevay, Indiana
30.7 miles from Butlerville, IN
A ghostly Lady in White in Victorian attire haunts the second floor of this 1874 bed-and-breakfast building, originally built as a mansion of a home for Benjamin Franklin Schenk. She is said to walk the hallways, taking no notice of anyone around her. Guests also have reported hearing voices, footsteps, ...
Read more » -
0
Greendale Cemetery
Greendale, Indiana
35.3 miles from Butlerville, IN
White or gray apparitions have been seen, and locals say that passing the graves belonging to the Tebbs family will give you chills and an uneasy feeling of being watched. Cold breezes have been reported here on hot, windless days.
Read more » -
0
Whisky's Restaurant
Lawrenceburg, Indiana
35.4 miles from Butlerville, IN
This restaurant began as two private houses that were combined to make a button factory. A former resident, an elderly lady died in the room now called the Malt Room, and her spirit is believed to remain here. A waitress reported feeling a tug on her apron when no one ...
Read more » -
0
Mount Zion Cemetery
Henryville, Indiana
37.3 miles from Butlerville, IN
A ghostly Green Lady is said to be the spirit of a young woman killed in a car accident nearby. She was buried here and now is said to walk its grounds, glowing green. It is said that if you park at the cemetery at night, she may cover it ...
Read more » -
0Story Inn
Nashville, Indiana
37.9 miles from Butlerville, IN
Reportedly haunted by a female ghost who appears most often in a specific room when a blue table lamp is turned on. For this reason the ghost has been dubbed "The Blue Lady". There are numerous reports of the Blue Lady ghost and the owner (who claims to ...
Read more » -
0
The Big Green Castle
Harrison, Ohio
40.4 miles from Butlerville, IN
This Victorian manor house is now a private residence, but back when it was abandoned and for sale, residents reported seeing figures in period clothing looking out of the windows and seeing lights moving around the house. (Submitted by Callum Swift)
Read more » -
0
Big Bone Lick Park
Union, Kentucky
42.3 miles from Butlerville, IN
Folks visiting the park have reported disembodied whispers, eerie figures, strange noises and an evil spirit who is said to linger in the nearby woods.
Read more » -
0
Hebron Lutheran Cemetery
Hebron, Kentucky
43.7 miles from Butlerville, IN
There has been many sightings here, and I have personally been here multiple times, and have had many experiences. When you approach the crematorium, you can always smell something burning, even if there is no one there. As well, when approaching graves, you can feel a chill and sometimes ...
Read more » -
0
Rails Restaurant
La Grange, Kentucky
43.9 miles from Butlerville, IN
The restaurant, housed in a building that's more than a century and a half old, is home to a ghostly little girl. She has been seen in the parking lot as well as the back of the restaurant, and wears a white dress and a hair bow. She is believed ...
Read more » -
0
Kopper Kettle Inn Restaurant
Morristown, Indiana
45.2 miles from Butlerville, IN
Not only is this local historic eatery known for its delicious family-style chicken dinner, it's also known for being haunted by several spirits.
Read more » -
0
Allegheny Airlines Flight 853 Crash Site
Fairland, Indiana
45.7 miles from Butlerville, IN
A plane accident killed 83 people back in 1969. At the site of the accident, body parts were scattered around and had to be buried over. Now, at this area, EVP's can be picked up as well as weird light anomalies in photographs. (Submitted by Chris)
Read more » -
0
Tunnelton Tunnel
Bedford, Indiana
46.5 miles from Butlerville, IN
The apparition of a man who was decapitated during the tunnel's construction has been reported; many folks say he appears to be searching for his head. One rumor states that there is a graveyard atop the tunnel, and during its construction, some of the bodies fell through into the tunnel. ...
Read more » -
0
Allendale Tunnel
Elsmere, Kentucky
48.8 miles from Butlerville, IN
Legend has it that a man hanged himself years ago in this tunnel, and the hook still protrudes from which he hung his rope. Witnesses say they have seen his apparition hanging here or walking in the tunnel and heard his screams.
Read more » -
0
Westwood Town Hall
Cincinnati, Ohio
49.6 miles from Butlerville, IN
The late-1880s Westwood Town Hall used to hold a volunteer fire department in the basement, a jail, meeting rooms, and an auditorium. Legend has it that it's haunted by a deceased security guard named Willy who hanged himself in his apartment on the premises after losing his job. He is ...
Read more » -
0
Narrows Road
Erlanger, Kentucky
50 miles from Butlerville, IN
A phantom officer in a '50s police car haunts Narrows Road, locals say, pulling over living drivers late at night. The ghost is said to be the lingering spirit of a cop who was hit and killed by a car here while making a traffic stop in the 1950s. Some ...
Read more » -
0
St. Joe Road Cemetery
New Albany, Indiana
50.5 miles from Butlerville, IN
An alleged hanging tree at St. Joe Road Cemetery is said to be the root (no pun intended) of the hauntings here. The tree stands in the middle of the cemetery, and rumor has it that looking toward it from the back of the cemetery at night, you can see ...
Read more » -
0
Sedamsville Rectory
Cincinnati, Ohio
50.8 miles from Butlerville, IN
Over a century old, the rectory is believed to be haunted. Witnesses working on building renovations have seen eerie mists and shadows under the doors of empty rooms. Some say one ghost who resides here is Father Donald MacLeod, who wrote "The History of Roman Catholicism in North America." In ...
Read more » -
0
Revenant Acres Farm
Charlottesville, Indiana
52.5 miles from Butlerville, IN
An old farmhouse dating back to the 1800s known to locals as a hot-spot for paranormal activity. An old woman's presence is felt by some. Others have claimed to have experienced poltergeist activity.
Read more » -
0
Cincinnati Union Terminal and Museum Center
Cincinnati, Ohio
52.6 miles from Butlerville, IN
The ghost of a former security guard who was murdered there still haunts the building at night, rattling the door knobs and checking the locks on the doors. A World War I plane exhibit is haunted by the ghost of a pilot. Visitors have reported seeing the ghostly aviator in ...
Read more » -
0
Stepp Cemetery
Martinsville, Indiana
52.8 miles from Butlerville, IN
Small Stepp Cemetery has about 25 graves and features in many local legends, from its founding by cult members to a grieving mother who committed suicide here after losing her baby. Her apparition, according to witnesses, appears dressed in black and crying over the baby's grave.
Read more » -
0
Middendorf-Bullock Funeral Home
Covington, Kentucky
53.5 miles from Butlerville, IN
This historic home was formerly a boarding house for students at a nearby mortuary college, and is rumoured to be haunted. Staff claim to have felt a strange in the building after dark, and have seen a shadowy male apparition on the landing. (Submitted by Callum Swift)
Read more » -
0Cincinnati Music Hall
Cincinnati, Ohio
53.6 miles from Butlerville, IN
Haunts have been reported at this historic music hall since the 1870s. It is said that when an elevator shaft was installed in 1988, bones of both children and adults were found under the building.
Read more » -
0
Stenton House - Cornell Place Apartments
Cincinnati, Ohio
53.6 miles from Butlerville, IN
There have been numerous deaths reported in these historic apartments. Disembodied footsteps and ghostly voices are heard in the old building when on one is around. (Submitted by Callum Swift)
Read more » -
0
Sherman Tavern
Dry Ridge, Kentucky
53.6 miles from Butlerville, IN
The Sherman Tavern is a historic former tavern built in 1812, which is in the process of being restored by local residents. It was a former stage stop for cattle drovers and American Indians. People restoring the historic building have reported seeing the apparitions of Confederate soldiers, and African American ...
Read more » -
0Hilton Cincinnati Netherland Plaza
Cincinnati, Ohio
53.8 miles from Butlerville, IN
A ghostly Lady in Green walks the Hall of Mirrors and the mezzanine. She was seen often by construction workers in 1983, while the hotel was undergoing renovations. Legend has it that she was the wife of a worker who was killed during the hotel's construction in 1930. So the ...
Read more » -
0
Spring Grove Cemetery
Cincinnati, Ohio
53.8 miles from Butlerville, IN
Spring Grove Cemetery is said to have a haunted bust on a gravestone located in Lot 100. It is said to turn its head and watch those who walk past.
Read more » -
0
Guyer Opera House
Lewisville, Indiana
54.1 miles from Butlerville, IN
In the 1900s, tragedy struck when a young boy was killed when a bullet ricocheted during a Wild West gun show. His spirit, along with that of the founder O.K. Guyer, who died the same year his opera house opened, are said to haunt the building. Guyer's funeral was held ...
Read more » -
0Old Bridge Inn
Jeffersonville, Indiana
54.1 miles from Butlerville, IN
The house here was originally built in 1836, and is haunted by a kindly spirit. Locals think the ghost may be former owner Dr. Charles Hancock, a descendant of patriot John Hancock. Other spirits are said to reside here as well.
Read more » -
0
Culbertson Mansion
New Albany, Indiana
54.2 miles from Butlerville, IN
Built in 1867 by William S. Culbertson, the mansion, which cost $120,000 to build at that time, is said to be haunted. Witnesses have heard doors shut by themselves and footsteps upstairs when no one is up there. Its Carriage House has a dark story attached to it. It burned ...
Read more » -
0
Cincinnati Zoo
Cincinnati, Ohio
54.3 miles from Butlerville, IN
The ghost of a lioness has been heard following visitors and workers in the zoo late at night. Green eyes are also seen in darker buildings or at the end of corridors. (Submitted by Callum Swift)
Read more » -
0
Taft Museum of Art
Cincinnati, Ohio
54.4 miles from Butlerville, IN
The Taft Museum of Art, built in 1820 by Martin Baum, is said to be haunted by several ghosts. Annie is the most famous, the wife of Charles Phelps Taft, half-brother of President William Howard Taft. They are the ones who donated the building to the city in 1932. Annie ...
Read more » -
0
Cincinnati Art Museum
Cincinnati, Ohio
54.8 miles from Butlerville, IN
The Cincinnati Museum of Art is not only renowned for its prized art collection, it is also well known for the various paranormal occurrences there. The first apparition seen here is the seven foot tall figure of a misty black figure with no face, who has reportedly materializes from a ...
Read more » -
0Bobby Mackey's Music World
Newport, Kentucky
54.8 miles from Butlerville, IN
This night club is sometimes called "the most haunted night club in America." The building was once a slaughterhouse, but it has an even darker link. Alleged Satan worshippers Scott Jackson and Alonzo Walling were said to have killed Pearl Bryan in 1897; her headless body was found near the ...
Read more » -
0
Indiana University Bloomington
Bloomington, Indiana
54.8 miles from Butlerville, IN
Indiana University Bloomington is said to be haunted in several spots on campus. One is the Career Center, babies are heard crying, and at the Folklore Office a deceased department head has been seen. At the Indiana Memorial Union, suicide victims and a ghost dog roam, and apparitions have been ...
Read more » -
0Spring House Gazebo
Cincinnati, Ohio
54.9 miles from Butlerville, IN
In 1927 a wealthy and prominent business man and bootlegger murdered his wife Imogene in broad daylight and in front of a dozen witnesses (including her daughter) in the park's gazebo. She was on her way to the courthouse to divorce him and apparently, this was too much for ...
Read more » -
0
Eden Park
Cincinnati, Ohio
55 miles from Butlerville, IN
Imogene Remus, wife of notorious bootlegger George Remus, is rumored to haunt their former home. When George went to prison in the mid-1920s, Imogene sold all the furnishings in their mansion and many of his distilleries, essentially closing his business, and filed for divorce. On October 6, 1927, they were ...
Read more » -
0
Belle of Louisville
Louisville, Kentucky
55.1 miles from Butlerville, IN
The historic steamboat is rumored to be haunted by former Captain Ben Winters, who died on board of a heart attack, and possibly by other felled workers, one of whom was crushed to death when machinery was turned on by accident and one killed when the paddlewheel unexpectedly went into ...
Read more » -
0
Paul Ruster Park Cemetery
Indianapolis, Indiana
55.5 miles from Butlerville, IN
The ghost of a little boy who was killed beside the nearby train tracks is said to walk along the paths or the nearby roadway playing his harmonica.
Read more » -
0Christopher's Bed and Breakfast
Bellevue, Kentucky
55.7 miles from Butlerville, IN
This bed-and-breakfast inn was originally built as a 19th-century church. Among the unusual things that happen here: Apparitions have been spotted on the stairs, the piano plays by itself during the night, and disembodied voices and footsteps have also been reported.
Read more » -
Haunted Tales from The Region: Ghosts of Indiana's South Shore (Haunted America)
Dorothy Salvo Davis
» Cemeteries near Butlerville, IN
» Find museums in Butlerville, IN
