-
Revenant Acres Farm
Charlottesville, Indiana
4.1 miles from Carthage, IN
An old farmhouse dating back to the 1800s known to locals as a hot-spot for paranormal activity. An old woman's presence is felt by some. Others have claimed to have experienced poltergeist activity.
Read more » -
Kopper Kettle Inn Restaurant
Morristown, Indiana
8.1 miles from Carthage, IN
Not only is this local historic eatery known for its delicious family-style chicken dinner, it's also known for being haunted by several spirits.
Read more » -
Guyer Opera House
Lewisville, Indiana
12.6 miles from Carthage, IN
In the 1900s, tragedy struck when a young boy was killed when a bullet ricocheted during a Wild West gun show. His spirit, along with that of the founder O.K. Guyer, who died the same year his opera house opened, are said to haunt the building. Guyer's funeral was held ...
Read more » -
Hays Cemetery
Wilkinson, Indiana
13.8 miles from Carthage, IN
Hays Cemetery, aka Main Street Graveyard, is said to be home to a "devil's child" because of a plant that grows in the shape of a pitchfork on her grave. Visiting is not recommended at night, as much of the area is private property and you could be arrested for ...
Read more » -
Thornhaven Manor
New Castle, Indiana
14.6 miles from Carthage, IN
This curious haunt has been featured on Ghost Adventures and is quickly becoming one of the most talked about haunted locations for the innumerable amounts of paranormal activity occurring on the property. Sitting on seven acres this foreboding home is the site of murder, mysterious deaths, and rumored suicide. (Submitted ...
Read more » -
Ivy House
Fortville, Indiana
20.3 miles from Carthage, IN
Built in 1921 by Dr. Jess E. Ferrell, the Ivy House bed-and-breakfast inn is said to have a haunt that came with the purchase of an antique piano. The owners say the instrument brought with it a ghost who makes the decidely nonmusical sounds of banging and walking footsteps.
Read more » -
Allegheny Airlines Flight 853 Crash Site
Fairland, Indiana
20.4 miles from Carthage, IN
A plane accident killed 83 people back in 1969. At the site of the accident, body parts were scattered around and had to be buried over. Now, at this area, EVP's can be picked up as well as weird light anomalies in photographs. (Submitted by Chris)
Read more » -
Paul Ruster Park Cemetery
Indianapolis, Indiana
20.9 miles from Carthage, IN
The ghost of a little boy who was killed beside the nearby train tracks is said to walk along the paths or the nearby roadway playing his harmonica.
Read more » -
State Theatre
Anderson, Indiana
25.8 miles from Carthage, IN
The State Theatre was opened in 1930 with eco friendly geo thermal heat and air system way before it's time and an acoustically engineered dome for the best sound for the first talkies. People have felt and seen various apparitions and vague whisperings in several places in the ...
Read more » -
Rivoli Theatre
Indianapolis, Indiana
28.8 miles from Carthage, IN
The 1927 Rivoli Theatre is rumored to have been built atop Indian burial grounds. Witnesses have reported a wide array of hauntings that include apparitions, toilets that flush by themselves, faucets that turn on, a smoking cigarette butt that appeared in the ashtray out of nowhere, moving objects and things ...
Read more » -
Hannah House
Indianapolis, Indiana
30.4 miles from Carthage, IN
Some of the ghosts at this historic house are said to be hidden slaves, one of whom accidentally tripped over a lamp, igniting a house fire. Those killed were said to be buried in the very cellar where it happened. Witnesses have described a lot of activity in the cellar, ...
Read more » -
Hannah House
Indianapolis, Indiana
30.4 miles from Carthage, IN
The 1858 Hannah House, built by Alexander Hannah, was part of the Underground Railroad. Sadly, one night as a group of traveling slaves was sleeping, an oil lamp overturned and ignited the straw nearby, killing them all. Hannah buried their bodies in the cellar in an attempt to keep his ...
Read more » -
Slippery Noodle Inn
Indianapolis, Indiana
31.2 miles from Carthage, IN
The historic buildings that house the Slippery Noodle have been around for a while, since 1850, so it has its share of spirits. Among those seen are the ghosts of slaves, a cowboy, a caretaker, and a prostitute.
Read more » -
Indianapolis Athletic Club
Indianapolis, Indiana
31.2 miles from Carthage, IN
Built in the 1920s, the Indianapolis Athletic Club is believed to be haunted by the ghost of a fireman who attempts to wake up guests in the middle of the night. Reports say the man died in a fire that occurred here in 1992.
Read more » -
Indiana Repertory Theatre
Indianapolis, Indiana
31.4 miles from Carthage, IN
To avoid cold and rainy weather, a former artistic director used to jog indoors, around the upstairs mezzanine. He was killed suddenly when his nephew hit him with the car as he was jogging on a foggy day. Now, on cold and rainy days, witnesses say you can hear the ...
Read more » -
James Allison Mansion
Indianapolis, Indiana
33.9 miles from Carthage, IN
Built from 1911 to 1913, the mansion is said to be haunted. Sources may be a little girl who was visiting and drowned in the basement pool, or James Allison himself. The little girl's apparition has been seen, and witnesses also have reported voices in the attic, objects that move ...
Read more » -
Wheeler-Stokely Mansion
Indianapolis, Indiana
33.9 miles from Carthage, IN
Witnesses tell of an apparition of a man walking a dog and another ghost of a brunette woman who runs out a door and jumps into a phantom carriage. Some folks say they have been nudged off the dog walk, or had unexplained chills or uneasy feelings. Other apparitions have ...
Read more » -
Indiana Central State Hospital
Indianapolis, Indiana
33.9 miles from Carthage, IN
The 1848 Indiana Hospital for the Insane turned into the Central State Hospital in 1926. It is said to be haunted by many patients who suffered abuse here in the hospital's dark past. Witnesses have described shadows, apparitions, women's screams, electrical devices that turn on and off by themselves, unexplained ...
Read more » -
Earlham College
Richmond, Indiana
35.5 miles from Carthage, IN
Earlham College is a liberal arts college founded by Quakers in 1847. The college has a resident ghost in the Athletic and Wellness Center who is known to play basketball at night.
Read more » -
Starr Piano Building
Richmond, Indiana
36.2 miles from Carthage, IN
The late-1800s Starr Piano Company not only made and sold pianos and phonographs but also housed Gennett Records, which recorded jazz, blues and country artists including Louis Armstrong, Jelly Roll Morton and Hoagy Carmichael. The complex was partly demolished in the 1970s and the shell still stands. The area is ...
Read more » -
Quality Machine and Tool Works
Columbus, Indiana
40.7 miles from Carthage, IN
Quality Machine and Tool Works is rumored to be home to the ghost of a former employee who hanged himself because of an unrequited love. Shadowy apparitions and disappearing objects are blamed on the ghost.
Read more » -
O'Neal Bridge - Holiday Drive Bridge
Zionsville, Indiana
40.8 miles from Carthage, IN
O'Neal Bridge, aka Holiday Drive Bridge, was built around 1892 and restored in 2008-2009. The bridge may no longer be in use, according to reports. Legend has it that around this spot, a KKK lynching took place, and hauntings way stem from it. Witnesses have reported disembodied screams in the ...
Read more » -
Roads Hotel
Atlanta, Indiana
40.8 miles from Carthage, IN
The 1893 hotel, once patronized by John Dillinger, is rumored to be haunted by many spirits. Witnesses have reported shadows and apparitions of men, women and children as well as disembodied voices, footsteps, lights that work on their own, and doors that open and close--or even slam--by themselves.
Read more » -
Crump Theatre
Columbus, Indiana
41.5 miles from Carthage, IN
The 1874 Crump Theatre , once a vaudeville and opera house, is home to some spooky goings-on. Ghost men and children have been seen along with unexplained noises and fragrances. Music has been heard coming from the top of a stairway. Reports say the building is no longer open to ...
Read more » -
Avon Haunted Bridge
Avon, Indiana
44.8 miles from Carthage, IN
The Avon Haunted Bridge is a railroad bridge that was built in 1906, and legend has it that it's haunted. So the story goes, a mother was walking with her baby on the tracks when they fell to their deaths. Locals would say every time you drove under the bridge ...
Read more » -
Gray Hotel
Redkey, Indiana
47.7 miles from Carthage, IN
This 1912 former hotel now houses the offices of a paranormal investigative team, who claim that the building is one of the most haunted in the entire state. With its troubling past of murder, manslaughter and illegal activity, it isn't that hard to believe either. At least two, possibly ...
Read more » -
Avon Bridge
Danville, Indiana
49.5 miles from Carthage, IN
The Haunted Bridge of Avon is half mile south of U.S. Highway 36 on CR 625. It is said to be haunted by a ghost (or maybe two or three) who moans or cries tears onto the bridge. Some legends say it's Henry Johnson, a construction worker fond of the ...
Read more » -
Finch Cemetery
Portland, Indiana
50.6 miles from Carthage, IN
The late-1800s Finch Cemetery at the Jay County Conservation Club is said to hold the grave of a boy named Cinderella. Rumor has it that the gravestones here shift, or disappear. If you count the gravestones on the way to Cinderella's grave, you will count 13. But on the way ...
Read more » -
The Big Green Castle
Harrison, Ohio
52.6 miles from Carthage, IN
This Victorian manor house is now a private residence, but back when it was abandoned and for sale, residents reported seeing figures in period clothing looking out of the windows and seeing lights moving around the house. (Submitted by Callum Swift)
Read more » -
Stepp Cemetery
Martinsville, Indiana
54.3 miles from Carthage, IN
Small Stepp Cemetery has about 25 graves and features in many local legends, from its founding by cult members to a grieving mother who committed suicide here after losing her baby. Her apparition, according to witnesses, appears dressed in black and crying over the baby's grave.
Read more » -
St. Clair Memorial Hall
Greenville, Ohio
55.6 miles from Carthage, IN
St. Clair Memorial Hall was built in 1910 and has an old man's spirit lingering inside, folks say. The hall, where plays and musicals are performed, is haunted by a man who fell to his death while changing a light bulb.
Read more » -
Story Inn
Nashville, Indiana
55.9 miles from Carthage, IN
Reportedly haunted by a female ghost who appears most often in a specific room when a blue table lamp is turned on. For this reason the ghost has been dubbed "The Blue Lady". There are numerous reports of the Blue Lady ghost and the owner (who claims to ...
Read more » -
Papa John's Pizza
Seymour, Indiana
56.4 miles from Carthage, IN
At this Papa John's Pizza location, several witnesses have reported an apparition in a blue uniform and knocking sounds coming from the walls. The knocks seemed to come from the empty store adjacent to Papa John's.
Read more » -
Greendale Cemetery
Greendale, Indiana
57.2 miles from Carthage, IN
White or gray apparitions have been seen, and locals say that passing the graves belonging to the Tebbs family will give you chills and an uneasy feeling of being watched. Cold breezes have been reported here on hot, windless days.
Read more » -
Whisky's Restaurant
Lawrenceburg, Indiana
58.6 miles from Carthage, IN
This restaurant began as two private houses that were combined to make a button factory. A former resident, an elderly lady died in the room now called the Malt Room, and her spirit is believed to remain here. A waitress reported feeling a tug on her apron when no one ...
Read more » -
Bear's Mill
Greenville, Ohio
60.2 miles from Carthage, IN
Bear’s Mill, an operating water-powered mill and historic landmark, was built in 1849 by Gabriel Baer. It is said to be haunted by a former owner, whose ghost can be heard walking on the creaking floorboards upstairs when no one is there.
Read more » -
2220 N Armstrong St
Kokomo, Indiana
60.9 miles from Carthage, IN
2220 N. Armstrong Kokomo Indiana is now an empty lot. There is no longer a home on the property. It was burned by a serial arsonist. He caused more than 22 structural fires in Kokomo. My childhood home was his last. The arsonist lived ...
Read more » -
Kaup Pharmacy - Homestead Restaurant
Portland, Ohio
62.7 miles from Carthage, IN
Once known as Homestead Food and Spirits, the building that houses the Kaup Pharmacy is said to have a ghostly resident. A lady's apparition has been spotted, and the door to the women's restroom has been known to open and close on its own.
Read more » -
Sorg Opera House and Mansion
Middletown, Ohio
63.9 miles from Carthage, IN
The opera house is haunted by the ghost of former residents, who can be heard walking around the house and talking late at night. The ghost of an actress in a red dress has been seen in the dressing rooms, but she vanishes when approached. She has also been heard ...
Read more » -
Indiana University Bloomington
Bloomington, Indiana
64.3 miles from Carthage, IN
Indiana University Bloomington is said to be haunted in several spots on campus. One is the Career Center, babies are heard crying, and at the Folklore Office a deceased department head has been seen. At the Indiana Memorial Union, suicide victims and a ghost dog roam, and apparitions have been ...
Read more » -
Florentine Hotel and Restaurant
Germantown, Ohio
64.3 miles from Carthage, IN
The 1816 hotel and restaurant is haunted. Staff and diners have experienced an eerie presence on the third floor, and the mezzanine is haunted by a poltergeist that causes the chandeliers to swing to and fro. (Submitted by Callum Swift)
Read more » -
Hebron Lutheran Cemetery
Hebron, Kentucky
65.9 miles from Carthage, IN
There has been many sightings here, and I have personally been here multiple times, and have had many experiences. When you approach the crematorium, you can always smell something burning, even if there is no one there. As well, when approaching graves, you can feel a chill and sometimes ...
Read more » -
Westwood Town Hall
Cincinnati, Ohio
66 miles from Carthage, IN
The late-1880s Westwood Town Hall used to hold a volunteer fire department in the basement, a jail, meeting rooms, and an auditorium. Legend has it that it's haunted by a deceased security guard named Willy who hanged himself in his apartment on the premises after losing his job. He is ...
Read more » -
The Screaming Bridge of Maud Hughes Road
Carthage, Ohio
66.3 miles from Carthage, IN
Maud Hughes Road has a haunted bridge known to locals as the Screaming Bridge. Locals say it has been the site of at least 36 deaths through accidents and suicides. Witnesses have reported apparitions, mists, hooded figures, strange lights, and a phantom train on the tracks below. There are many, ...
Read more » -
Cloverdale Cemetery
Cloverdale, Indiana
66.6 miles from Carthage, IN
The 1800s Cloverdale Cemetery is rumored to have the graves of seven beautiful witch sisters. Many urban legends center on the sisters, such as that those who walk around their graves seven times by the light of a full moon would awaken the sisters' ghosts, which would chase them away. ...
Read more » -
Spring Grove Cemetery
Cincinnati, Ohio
68.6 miles from Carthage, IN
Spring Grove Cemetery is said to have a haunted bust on a gravestone located in Lot 100. It is said to turn its head and watch those who walk past.
Read more » -
Ceylon Covered Bridge
Geneva, Indiana
69 miles from Carthage, IN
Local legend has it that many years ago a group of teens performed a séance here, during which a body fell to the floor, leaving a big blood stain near the pentagram they drew. The experience is rumored to have opened a portal from which strange things come.
Read more » -
Hamilton Road
Mulberry, Indiana
69.2 miles from Carthage, IN
Stories about Hamilton Road are of the urban legend type. For example, a ghost of a short man will chase you if you stop on the third bridge and flash your lights four times, then cross the bridge. Phantom flames are said to come from the woods where an 1800s ...
Read more » -
Stenton House - Cornell Place Apartments
Cincinnati, Ohio
69.2 miles from Carthage, IN
There have been numerous deaths reported in these historic apartments. Disembodied footsteps and ghostly voices are heard in the old building when on one is around. (Submitted by Callum Swift)
Read more » -
Sedamsville Rectory
Cincinnati, Ohio
69.9 miles from Carthage, IN
Over a century old, the rectory is believed to be haunted. Witnesses working on building renovations have seen eerie mists and shadows under the doors of empty rooms. Some say one ghost who resides here is Father Donald MacLeod, who wrote "The History of Roman Catholicism in North America." In ...
Read more »
» Cemeteries near Carthage, IN
» Find museums in Carthage, IN