-
0U.S. Route 322
Cranberry, Pennsylvania
14.6 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
General Anthony Wayne was buried, unearthed, then boiled so he could be transferred to his family grave. It is said that he lost some bones along the way and was reburied as an incomplete body. Some people still see him wandering along this road (used to transfer him); he is ...
Read more » -
0Days Inn Meadville
Meadville, Pennsylvania
20.3 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
Witnesses at this Days Inn have been startled to see apparitions in the main building's kitchen and second-floor hallway. Spirits are said to tamper with the radio and lights, and unexplained footsteps and thumps have been heard from vacant rooms and in the hallways. Doors also have been known to ...
Read more » -
0
Grove City College
Grove City, Pennsylvania
20.9 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
Grove City College's Lily Room is the stuff of legend. Campus lore says it's a locked-up room in a girls' dorm in which a girl hanged herself. Rumor has it the room was locked for 15 years and when it was opened again, her lily perfume was still heavy in ...
Read more » -
0
133 Kiester Road
Slippery Rock, Pennsylvania
26.5 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
The house at this address is apparently haunted by a malevolent spirit that many people believe to be Sam Mohawk a Native American mass murderer who was hanged for murdering a woman and her five children near the place this house stands.
Read more » -
0Hotel Conneaut
Conneaut Lake, Pennsylvania
26.7 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
Several ghosts are said to haunt this hotel including a ghost bride who allegedly died in a fire, a young child who died after falling down the stairs, and even a mad butcher who was dismembered in the kitchen. If you are looking for a haunted room, the Elizabeth's ...
Read more » -
0Riverside Inn
Cambridge Springs, Pennsylvania
28 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
At this historic 1880s inn, the spirits have been known to crawl into bed with guests, dance in the ballroom to ghostly music, and open and close the doors.
Read more » -
0
Hunter Mansion
Tidioute, Pennsylvania
30.7 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
The library of the 1874 mansion is rumoured to be haunted. The apparition of a woman in an old-fashioned dress, perhaps the wife of the original owner, has appeared to visitors on several occasions. (Submitted by Callum Swift)
Read more » -
0Snyder Cemetery
Slippery Rock, Pennsylvania
31.4 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
Numerous paranormal events are reported at this location, but few precise details are available.
Read more » -
0Knickerbocker Hotel
Linesville, Pennsylvania
32.4 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
This historic hotel is not your average lodging place. Yes, you can spend the night for a fee, but as they will tell you, you won't sleep. The paranormal activity is said to be rich here, because some guests checked in but did not check out.
Read more » -
0Eagle Hotel
Waterford, Pennsylvania
36.2 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
At this 1826 former hotel building, a restuarant called Sugar 'n Spice occupies the first floor and the second and third floors are a history museum. Mysterious sounds have been reported here, such as voices calling your name when no one is there, and a baby crying. Items are moved ...
Read more » -
0
Kinsman General Store
Kinsman, Ohio
36.6 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
This old-fashioned general store is believed to have a ghostly inhabitant in the basement, and is generally off limits to the public and visitors. Staff have reported seeing an old man smoking a pipe in the basement, and visitors have also smelt the overwhelming aroma of tobacco smoke on all ...
Read more » -
0
Market Square Building
Kinsman, Ohio
36.7 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
This building features both an old-fashioned book store and a fascinating antiques market, which are both believed to be haunted. In the book store section of the building, staff report an entity that pushes books off shelves, and has been known to rearrange furniture while they are in the basement. ...
Read more » -
0
Downtown New Castle
New Castle, Pennsylvania
37.8 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
New Castle's downtown and Historical North Hill have several haunted locations including the old Stritmater Building, the Wallace House, the Historical Society's Greer-Clavelli Mansion, the old Temple Building, and the Joseph White House. Apparitions have been seen in some of the buildings and ghost hunters have recorded activity in others. ...
Read more » -
0Hill View Manor
New Castle, Pennsylvania
38.4 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
The historic manor was once a nursing home, and folks claimed the spirit of a little boy would pay a visit now and then. It was said that those who saw him would pass away shortly. Witnesses also have reported full-body manifestations that float through walls.
Read more » -
0
Bucktail Hotel
Marienville, Pennsylvania
39.4 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
Guests staying at this 1937 hotel have reported a spook haunting the upstairs rooms. The entity is believed to be a poltergeist, as it has been known to move objects around. (Submitted by Callum Swift)
Read more » -
0
Hell's Corners
Hubbard, Ohio
39.7 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
In Hubbard, Ohio, the area where Pathour Wheeler Road and John White Road intersect is known to locals as "Hell's Corners." It is said that a young native American boy was shot on this spot many years ago, and that a jail once stood here where many hangings took ...
Read more » -
0
Jaquins Pond
Clymer, New York
43.5 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
Jaquin's Pond is legendary in local ghost stories. The area is basically a swampy woodland with some narrow dirt roads through it and three bridges. All three bridges are said to be haunted by George, a former school bus driver who killed himself in despair when a little boy died ...
Read more » -
0
Gudgeonville Covered Bridge
Girard, Pennsylvania
43.6 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
Even though the bridge was destroyed by an arsonist in 2008, activity has not stopped. EVP's are picked up; a little girl (believed to be a girl who fell from nearby cliffs) is thought to be one of the voices that is picked up as well other unrecognizable voices. Light ...
Read more » -
0
Kline Opera House
Cortland, Ohio
44.3 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
This historic opera house was formerly the town church, built in the mid nineteenth century and the first in the surrounding county. The ghostly events surrounding the opera house began in the 1980's, when staff closing up the opera house for the night began to hear loud crashing noises and ...
Read more » -
0
Pauni Apartments
Cortland, Ohio
44.3 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
These recently constructed apartments were built over the top of an ancient burial ground, and residents have reported paranormal occurrences in the building ever since. Doors open and close by themselves, objects move around by themselves and the apparition of a man in a sombrero has been seen in the ...
Read more » -
0
Axe Murder Hollow
McKean, Pennsylvania
44.3 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
On the dirt roads and wooded area behind Thomas Rd is where an axe murderer supposedly went on a rampage. One of the victims, a young woman, has been reported running and screaming as if she is being chased. (Submitted by Chris Berglund)
Read more » -
0Harmony Inn
Harmony, Pennsylvania
44.6 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
Local legend has it that this restaurant is haunted by two spirits: a ghost named Louie and the apparition of a woman. Louie was allegedly killed right outside on the inn's front steps. The ghostly woman is seen near the entranceway, between the bar and the dining room.
Read more » -
0
Wintergreen Gorge
Erie, Pennsylvania
48.1 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
The ghost of a boy, named Tim (who died in his twenties, but appears as a child) and his dog (Dutch) have been seen along the trails. The pair would often hike there until Dutch died; Tim was later killed in a car accident but has been reported here. (Submitted ...
Read more » -
0
Erie Cemetery
Erie, Pennsylvania
48.8 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
There's blackened areas as if they have burned; some say that they have been scorched in Satanic rituals. Visitors feel as if they are being followed or like someone is standing behind them. (Submitted by Chris Berglund)
Read more » -
0
Summit Cut Bridge
Darlington, Pennsylvania
49.1 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
On Shenango Road, just before it meets Ashwood Road, is Summit Cut Bridge (sometimes incorrectly referred to as Summer Cut Bridge). The bridge, locals say, has a ghostly white lady. Legend has it that she fell off the bridge onto the railroad tracks in 1894. Her spirit is said to ...
Read more » -
0
The Brewerie at Union Station
Erie, Pennsylvania
49.4 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
A girl named Clara fell down the staircase here; staff, visitors, and investigators believe that she is still here, even creating a beer dedicated to the beloved ghost! (Submitted by Chris Berglund)
Read more » -
0
Nicky's Pub
Erie, Pennsylvania
49.7 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
Before it was Nicky's Pub, this building served as a variety of business venues, even rumored to have mafia and prostitution connections. Nowadays, guests have reported a man in a long coat floating along the East Hallway. Guests have reported the common paranormal phenomenon (disembodied voices, electronic devices acting strangely, ...
Read more » -
0
Cathedral of St Paul
Erie, Pennsylvania
49.9 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
Members of the congregation believe a little girl named Katie still remains here. After her death in a car accident, members would report hearing a jovial laugh similar to Katie's, but also the sound of heavy objects moving around in empty rooms. The church organ has played by itself before ...
Read more » -
0
Watson-Curtze Mansion
Erie, Pennsylvania
49.9 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
General Anthony Wayne was initially buried here, but he was boiled down by his family before being transferred to a family plot. The cauldron itself is still located here and is said to rattle and make noises. A little girl is also said to be seen on the second floor ...
Read more » -
0
Gannon University
Erie, Pennsylvania
50 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
Legend has it that a fraternity costume party had a guest dressed as a cowboy who disappeared upstairs, then was responsible for poltergeist activity inside of the house. While that story is more debatable, students commonly report activity in Schuster Theatre. (Submitted by Chris Berglund)
Read more » -
0
Cleveland Hotel
Conneaut, Ohio
50.1 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
This century-old building was purchased in 2012 and is slated to be renovated into condominiums. It was once a fashionable hotel, but fell into disrepair and was known as a hang-out for the homeless for several decades. There are rumors about a "ghost bride" that some believe to ...
Read more » -
0
Warren City Hall
Warren, Ohio
50.5 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
This historic mansion was built in 1871, and was turned into the town hall sometime later. The grounds of the beautiful mansion are haunted by a woman responsible for the death of her beloved nephew, who has been seen wandering around after hours calling his name, Night staff also report ...
Read more » -
0
Austintown Log House
Canfield, Ohio
50.7 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
There have been reported sightings of the apparition of a headless soldier in the historic log cabin. He is seen in various rooms of the house, as well as by motorists driving past the house in an upstairs window. (Submitted by Callum Swift)
Read more » -
0
Old Crowley Mansion Site
Erie, Pennsylvania
51.8 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
The home that once occupied this area was said to be Erie's first haunted house, but now, only a field remains here. The Crowley family were rich, but plagued with tragedy including murder, illness, and untimely death. One of those who was murdered (by his wife) chose to torment her ...
Read more » -
0
Kingsville Public Library
Kingsville, Ohio
52.3 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
In the older section of 1885 Kingsville Public Library, folks say the apparition of a man in a tall black hat wanders the stacks. Strange noises and events have been reported as well. Many believe the library is haunted by several spirits.
Read more » -
0Culmerville Hotel - Zottola's Pub and Eatery
Tarentum, Pennsylvania
53 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
A spirit is said to reside in the former Culmervilel Hotel, now Zottola's Pub and Eatery.
Read more » -
0
Brush Creek Inn
Warrendale, Pennsylvania
54 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
Keep watch for airborne bottles if you visit Brush Creek Inn! It is said that the spirits at the restaurant will shatter bottles at the bar or hurl them across the room. Witnesses also have reported that the windows open and close by themselves and furniture flips over.
Read more » -
0
Chestnut Grove Cemetery
Ashtabula, Ohio
55.3 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
Chestnut Grove Cemetery was once an Erie burial ground and, since its establishment in 1819, has seen the burial of over 18,000 folks. Twenty-five of them were victims of a local train disaster in 1876. The Pacific Express fell into the river when the bridge collapsed, killing between 80 and ...
Read more » -
0
The Village Casino
Bemus Point, New York
56.7 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
The Village Casino is a teen dance hall rumored to be haunted by the ghost of former teenaged chef Jordan Basile, who died in an explosion due to a malfunctioning oven. The ghost makes himself known by causing food to disappear and dancers to trip over nothing on the dance ...
Read more » -
0
Hotel Lenhart
Bemus Point, New York
56.8 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
Hotel Lenhart, which dates back to 1880s, was rebuilt in 1890 after a fire and partially restored again in 1941, after another fire. An unknown haunt is said to reside in the building, opening and closing doors and tugging at the hair of visitors.
Read more » -
0
Allegheny-Kiski Valley Heritage Museum
Tarentum, Pennsylvania
56.9 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
A former volunteer named Jack is commonly seen in the basement. He is said to be seen mostly around the old gardening tools. (Submitted by Chris Berglund)
Read more » -
0
Lucille Ball Little Theatre
Jamestown, New York
57.1 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
According to rumors, the historic Lucille Ball Little Theatre has been the setting for many reports of ghostly apparitions and other paranormal phenomena.
Read more » -
0
Summit Hose Company
Tarentum, Pennsylvania
57.2 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
Voices and odd noises are heard, doors open by themselves, and shadows have been seen here. (Submitted by Chris Berglund)
Read more » -
0
Depreciation Lands Museum
Hampton Township, Pennsylvania
57.2 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
A rather helpful man in a long coat and out-of-date boots has been responsible for catching a painter's ladder after the man lost his balance, catching a cleaning woman who fell, fixing a broken window, and saving a group of girl scouts when the ceiling collapsed over them. (Submitted by ...
Read more » -
0
Hollenbeck Cemetery
Jamestown, New York
59.5 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
Tiny Hollenbeck Cemetery, with about 25 graves, hasn't been used since before the turn of the century. But legends abound about the place; folks have witnessed a headless horseman, a woman in white, ghostly babies crying, screams for help, knocking sounds, orbs, and tombstones that are said to have disappeared. ...
Read more » -
0
Egypt Road Bridge
Salem, Ohio
59.9 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
The closed Egypt Road Bridge, or Crybaby Bridge, is haunted day and night by the sound of a crying baby. Legend has it that a baby went missing while its parents were fighting, and it fell over the side of the bridge. The scream of its mother and the crying ...
Read more » -
0
Kelly Road
Industry, Pennsylvania
60.1 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
This road, also called the Mystery Mile by residents, is said to be haunted. What else could the explanation be for strange white apparitions and the tendency for animals here to turn from tame to fierce and bloodthirsty? Strange sounds are also heard along this road and in the forest ...
Read more » -
0
Dewittville Cemetery - Poor House Cemetery
Dewittville, New York
61.2 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
Dewittville Cemetery, aka Poor House Cemetery, was a place to bury the poor folks who were housed here and passed away. The cemetery was in use between 1833 and 1918, although grave markers weren't used until 1869. The cemetery, barn and woods are said to be full of spirits who ...
Read more » -
0
Gurnsey Hollow Cemetery
Frewsburg, New York
61.8 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
Gurnsey Hollow Cemetery has gravesites that date back to the 1800s and a tragic story to boot. Legend has it that long ago, a mentally handicapped girl, age 7, was stoned to death here by a gang of townsfolk. The reason for the witch hunt is unknown. Her body is ...
Read more » -
0
The Step Above Lounge and Wine Bar
Geneva, Ohio
61.9 miles from Sugarcreek, PA
The Step Above is a bar housed over a restaurant that closes earlier, and bar patrons have seen shadowy figures moving about inside the locked restaurant after closing.
Read more »
» Cemeteries near Sugarcreek, PA
» Find museums in Sugarcreek, PA
